top of page

The French Suites BWV 812 - 817

Bach_The French Suites.jpeg
back The French Suites.jpg

https://www.discantica.it/img/discantica/libretti/libretto311.pdf

 

 

From the booklet edited by Marco Moiraghi:

 

This recording offers the listener the possibility to listen the entire series of six French Suites BWV 812-817 by Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750) performed on the harp. For Cristiana Passerini this is her second  recording of Bach's works, following her successful recording of three other Suites belonging to the ungrouped works by Bach (BWV 996, 997 and 1006a). Her previous recording presented three works originally composed for lute or also for harpsichord, or rather, most probably, for that unique hybrid instrument  called Lautenwerk or Lautenclavicymbel,  which Bach so admired (he had two of them). After her first exploration of rather rare works, this new recording for harp concentrates on more familiar ones, especially for those who teach piano and harpsichord. Therefore we are given an opportunity, thanks to this recording, to reflect upon not only the stylistic density of the complete series of French Suites, but also the unique timbres and expression used in adapting Bach's music for the harp.

 

Finally, I should like to make a few comments on the instrumental aspects of this recording, which condenses these six wonderful pieces by Bach into one listening experience. The harpist has used eight fingers, instead of the usual ten used by normal keyboard performances, which creates special difficulty requires constant effort by the performer to control fingering. In any case, Bach's writing is completely respected to the last detail: the use of a harp did not involve any simplification whatsoever. It was required that the pedals remained absolutely silent, so that there would be no eventual disturbing mechanical noises or vibrations. As for the dynamics, the harpist has opted for a moderate use of the harp's variety of colours in favour of timbre differentiation which evokes a lute-like or harpsichord-like effect: sounds produced near the soundboard, 'angelic' sounds produced near the soundbox, the insertion of material between the strings (strips of cloth), and a differentiation of the same voices using various positions on the strings.

This recording, together with Cristiana Passerini's earlier recording of Bach's musica, represent a significant effort to fill a gap. The general absence of Bach in studies for harp is undoubtedly a relevant loss. There is also an expansion pf the harp repertoire from18th century keyboard and violin music, but as for now, it is only sporadic. The great educational value of Bach's music, as remembered above in reference to the French Suites, can also be stated for the harp, an instrument which can take full of advantage of the assiduous practice of Bach's great instrumental works.

Johann Sebastian Bach

The French Suites

BWV 812 - 817

 

Quantity: 2 CDs

 

5-STARS-295x160.jpeg

MUSIC Magazine 5 Stars

April 2021

 

By now there is no instrumentalist who does not feel obliged to dedicate some transcription of Bach's works to his instrument: thus, even recently, we have had adaptations for recorder, cello piccolo, viola, lute, theorbo, guitar, mandolin of compositions conceived for completely different ensembles: these are versions that in some cases can be considered excellent (I am thinking for example of the Cello Suites transcribed for viola da braccio and performed by Tabea Zimmermann, or the lute versions of the Sonatas and Partitas for solo violin and the Cello Suites created by Hopkinson Smith), in others more questionable or even improbable (such as those presented in the album entitled The Melancholic Bach, reviewed in this magazine at the time). Naturally, the case of piano transcriptions of harpsichord or organ compositions is different, now linked to a centuries-old teaching and performance tradition. In this context, therefore, the harp could not be missing, an instrument to which Bach left no trace (unlike Handel): hence the personal contribution of the harpist Cristiana Passerini, who, after the interesting results achieved with a previous CD dedicated to the same author, wanted to transcribe the harpsichord French Suites BWV 812-817: and let's say right away that in this case the timbre of the instrument did not seem so far from that of the harpsichord (often also equipped with registers, including the lute one), or so jarring compared to it, resulting in fact not a little suggestive, at least in these works, given the achieved timbre sweetness (after all, in the past there has been no shortage of harp transcriptions for works belonging to the same period). The motivation for this operation is, in essence, convincing and fully shareable, considering the absence, in the educational field, of Bach's works expressly conceived for the harp: a gap such as to deprive students of a fundamental repertoire both from the technical point of view and from that of training in taste and sensitivity, given that the composer himself, as is known, had intended many of his creations for these purposes. If we then take into account the artistic results achieved here by Passerini, we cannot but be grateful for this proposal that allows us to have a sound image of all these compositions of notable impact for expressive value and for executive ability, also in consideration of the technical commitment required by creations conceived for a keyboard instrument (the harpist, in fact, does not have the ten fingers of the keyboard player at his disposal, having to use only eight): so if the French Suites for every harpsichordist or pianist are of medium technical difficulty, for a harpist they are much more demanding. A round of applause, then, to the performer, who in this approach was able to fully render the spirit and the peculiarities of the writing of all these works (also given the full respect of the author's original dictation, including the embellishments), obtaining an adequate range of nuances, without resorting to particular artifices, and thus letting the music flow naturally and easily, even though some phonic harshness was inevitable (especially evident in the technically more demanding Suites, including the splendid one in D minor and the one in G major). Finally, admirable is the delicacy and sensitivity with which several pages were outlined: the Sarabande, in particular, but also many of the Allemande, among which those of the Suites no. 3, no. 4 and no. 5 deserve a mention). In addition to making use of a recording of notable impact for phonic presence and naturalness of timbre, the double CD has been enriched with a booklet including extensive and detailed introductory notes also offered in Italian.

Claudio Bolzan

bottom of page